Federal judge denies defendants' motions to dismiss Craft lawsuit, orders clarification
by Lydia Senn
19 months ago | 2391 views | 4 4 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Tonya Craft
Tonya Craft
slideshow
A federal judge has denied motions to dismiss a lawsuit filed by former Chickamauga City Schools teacher Tonya Craft, who was found not guilty of 22 counts of child molestation in May.

The order allows Craft to pursue her $25 million lawsuit against 15 defendants she says defamed her and caused her emotional and financial damage. Defendants include her ex-husband, the Catoosa County Sheriff’s Department, Catoosa County and two child advocacy groups.

The 37-page order signed by Judge Harold L. Murphy of Rome also requires Craft to file a more specific complaint within two weeks.

The judge asked Craft to be more specific about her allegations. The order, signed Tuesday, also states that Craft has failed to set forth specific facts supporting her conspiracy claim. Also, the defamation claim fails to identify when the allegedly defamatory statements were made and who made them.

Craft alleged in the initial lawsuit that her constitutional rights to due process were violated when she was arrested and held without probable cause. The suit also claims defamation of character and intentional emotional distress.

“Had anyone conducted a minimal investigation a reasonable person would have seen that the allegations were meritless,” the lawsuit states.

Comments
(4)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
justbeingme71
|
July 08, 2010
WAY TO GO TONYA!!! HOPE YOU GET ALL THAT YOU ASK FOR$$$$....
LDJVR
|
July 07, 2010
Hopefully this Judge is not a member of the good ole boy (Lookout Mountain Judicial Circuit) club! Maybe he'll uphold the law and teach a lesson to all Tonya's accusers and any other prosecutors who want to railroad innocent people for Mondale Act money!! Hope he makes those witch hunters pay every last dime of the $25 million to Tonya!
hoyt28
|
July 07, 2010
Finaly a judge with a brain. Good for Tonya and hope she gets every penny she has sued for.
suetiggers
|
July 07, 2010
Few know/care how many of these kind of cases there are and that the sex offender laws are not protecting children one whit more. But they have hurt many men, mostly who aren't dangerous.The hysteria feeds false accusations. The Craft case just proves it can happen to women too.

My son Ken's story is one.But I've learned there are too many more.I've worked years in Child Protective Services on child sexual abuse cases&theres another side to these stories. Because of a few heinous sex abuse cases by strangers, the laws now have MOSTLY men who are on the registries who aren't dangerous, &especially not to children. Few people believe a child would lie about sex. But, I saw cases of belligerent teens who lied to get back at a father or stepfather. And,an eight-year old girl lied about my mentally ill son. When she lied, this was suggested to her&encouraged by two adult women who did not like my son's looks or personality. Because of his illness, he was too friendly, too trusting w/people, he did not take care of his teeth& he had very bad acne. When this child lied, everyone listened. Now she has grown up,recanted, but few listen. She ended up giving a very strong deposition. This had much in it about how her grandmother & a nosy neighborhood watchperson gave her the idea because they didn't like my son's looks (he had very bad acne and teeth .Ken was/is phobic about dentists&had severe acne Marian grew up in a family/neighborhood filled w/prostitution and drugs. She had 3 criminal uncles living with her. Her older sister, who my naive son was in love with, was a prostitute and drug addict. This girls' mother was a prostitute/ drug addict.(now both dead of o'd's) Lying was a way of life in this girls' family/neighborhood.People bragged about putting people away by lying.In her deposition, Marian talked about trying to think about ways to get my son away from her sister; she was so jealous that he took this sister, who she was very close to, away from her.She said, her grandmother &the other woman gave her the idea.She said if anyone ever asked her to take a lie detector test, she would;vetold the truth.She was scared of going to court. Ken’s lawyer,knew my son's looks would hurt him made him believe that an Alford plea was his only option. The states' attorney said my son looked "wierd"too &he was so aggressive in going after my son that Ken’s first atty.said that she thought he “hates your son”. So, an attractive but lying child looked innocent &an unattractive but innocent man took a plea because it seemed there was no choice. Everyone listened when the girl lied.Few care now that she is finally telling the truth. My son has always been a gentle, good person who was taken advantage of by others because of his naiveté’ about people. http://www.citypaper.com/news/story.asp?id=1492212 help us change the laws: http://www.reformsexoffenderlaws.org/
Postings are not edited and are the responsibility of the author. You agree not to post comments that are abusive, threatening or obscene. Postings may be removed at our discretion.